Why do French women refuse to have Down's syndrome screening by maternal serum testing? A mixed methods study

Lafarge, Caroline ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0003-2148-078X, Larrieu, Gaëlle and Ville, Isabelle (2022) Why do French women refuse to have Down's syndrome screening by maternal serum testing? A mixed methods study. Midwifery, 110. p. 103351. ISSN 0266-6138

[thumbnail of Lafarge,_Larrieu_and_Ville_JMidwifery_2022_Why_do_French_women_refuse_to_have_Down’s_syndrome_screening_by_maternal_serum_testing_A_mixed_methods_study.pdf]
Lafarge,_Larrieu_and_Ville_JMidwifery_2022_Why_do_French_women_refuse_to_have_Down’s_syndrome_screening_by_maternal_serum_testing_A_mixed_methods_study.pdf - Accepted Version
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution.

Download (619kB) | Preview


The study aims to analyse the reasons underpinning women's refusal to undertake Down's syndrome screening (DSS) by maternal serum testing (MST).

A retrospective, mixed methods sequential approach was used. An online survey on women's experience of prenatal testing followed by in-depth interviews were conducted, with women over 18 years old, who had been pregnant within five years prior to the study. Altogether, 1726 responses were gathered, of which 217 related to women who had refused MST. The study compares the women who refused MST with women who accepted it on sociodemographic characteristics, the evolution and experience of the pregnancy, their knowledge about Down's syndrome (DS). It also utilises survey comments and five in-depth interviews to explore, using Thematic Analysis, the reasons for refusing MST.

To refuse MST is cognitively demanding. Indeed, women who refused MST were better educated, knew more about prenatal diagnosis sequences and DS than women who accepted it. This position is also emotionally challenging as women's interactions with practitioners can put them in difficult situations, where they have to defend their point of view. Reasons for refusing MST go beyond religious beliefs, negative attitudes towards abortion and/or medicalisation of pregnancy. Rather, women's position appears to be driven by a holistic conception of care-based monitoring, values of inclusivity and a desire to remain in control of their pregnancy.

It is essential that women feel accepted and supported in their choice to refuse MST. Consequently, it is important for professionals to remain cognisant of the diversity of factors underpinning women's decision, the pressure this position generates and the challenges that come with it.

Item Type: Article
Identifier: 10.1016/j.midw.2022.103351
Keywords: Down's syndrome screening, prenatal diagnosis, decision-making, women's experience
Subjects: Medicine and health > Midwifery
Related URLs:
Depositing User: Caroline Lafarge
Date Deposited: 25 Apr 2022 12:52
Last Modified: 06 Feb 2024 16:10
URI: https://repository.uwl.ac.uk/id/eprint/8994


Downloads per month over past year

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item